Article · In Film

Gilead built itself on a single verse. The verse was descriptive, not commanded.

Atwood and the Hulu adaptation imagine a regime that turns one Genesis verse into law. Read Genesis 30:3 — and notice the original is told as dysfunction, not as model.

Genesis 30:3

Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, both the 1985 novel and the Hulu series that began in 2017, is set in a near-future America renamed Gilead, after a Christian-coded coup has dissolved the Constitution. Fertile women are made handmaids — assigned to elite households where they are forcibly impregnated by the husband, then made to give the child to the wife. The ritual is called the Ceremony. The greeting is blessed be the fruit. The dystopia is built on the regime's claim to be following one verse of the Bible.

That verse is in Genesis 30. Rachel, who has not been able to bear children, has been competing with her sister Leah, who has. Rachel turns to her husband Jacob with a desperate proposal:

Genesis 30:3

"And she said, Behold my maid Bilhah, go in unto her; and she shall bear upon my knees, that I may also have children by her."

Bilhah is Rachel's slave-girl. She is given no voice in the negotiation. Jacob complies. The arrangement is later mirrored by Leah using her own maid, Zilpah. The four women between them — Rachel, Leah, Bilhah, Zilpah — produce the twelve sons who will become the tribes of Israel.

A Verse Atwood Read Carefully

Atwood, in her own essays, has noted that the founding verse of Gilead's theology is treated as prescriptive by the regime and descriptive by the original text. The Genesis story is not framed as a divine command. There is no thus saith the LORD before Rachel speaks. The whole arc — Rachel's bitterness, Leah's competition, Bilhah's silence, Jacob's passivity — is filmed in the ancient text as a portrait of family dysfunction.

The biblical narrator never says go and do likewise. The Genesis story ends, in fact, with Rachel and Leah dying, with Joseph being sold by his half-brothers, and with the covenant carrying forward despite the wreckage these arrangements caused, not because of it.

The series' horror, in part, is structural. Gilead has taken a verse that the original text presents as a wound and made it the law of the land.

The Verses Gilead Suppresses

The other half of the story is what Gilead leaves out. Atwood and the writers' room are careful to show that Gilead's regime quotes selectively. Blessed are the meek is read; love thy neighbor is buried. Most strikingly, the series shows that Gilead suppresses literacy itself. Women are forbidden to read. Why — Atwood implies — is obvious. A woman who can read can read past Genesis 30 and into the verses that complicate it.

One of those is Galatians 3:28: there is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus. The series never has a character recite it aloud. It does not need to. The handmaids' silence is the verse's absence.

What the Cameras Hold

The series' visual language is wedded to the verse it both honors and condemns. The handmaids' red dresses and white wings allude to medieval iconography of nuns and saints; the regime is dressing its handmaids in the visual codes of holiness while violating their bodies. The Ceremony is filmed in a theological tableau — Wife at the head of the bed, Handmaid below — that cites Genesis 30 in mise-en-scène. The cinematography is implicating the regime's own image-making.

When June, the protagonist, finally says they should not have given us uniforms if they didn't want us to be an army, she is doing what literate women have always done: reading past the verse the men in power have selected.

What the Bible Did with the Story

Two thousand years of Jewish and Christian commentary on Genesis 30 has been overwhelmingly uncomfortable with what happens in it. Rabbinic tradition reads the chapter as a tragedy. Christian readers have noted the parallel with Sarah/Hagar and have called both episodes what not to do. The Bible's own canon — in books like Hosea, Isaiah, the Gospels — repeatedly insists that God hears the voices that genealogies and laws have erased. Hagar names God in Genesis 16. Bilhah's voice never appears in Genesis. The series notices the gap and films it.

The Forty Seconds

Read Genesis 30:3 once. And she said, Behold my maid Bilhah, go in unto her; and she shall bear upon my knees, that I may also have children by her. Forty seconds. In that time, hold both readings. Gilead reads it as command. The text reads it as wound. The series exists in the gap between those two readings and dares the audience to know which one Scripture itself prefers.

The Ceremony is the spectacle. The verse is the misuse. The audience that can read for itself is the answer the regime fears.
Related